The BMI, or “body mass index,” is a common method to assess body composition. But how accurate is it really, and can it be used to predict health outcomes based on its weight/height ratio? There are other, less well-known tests that can accurately gauge fat composition of the body, but how useful are they? In this review, we’ll look at BMI and several alternatives to see which ones actually win the battle of the bulge.
Stepped on the scale this morning? Were the results to your liking? Well, you’re not alone: Everybody’s interested in their weight. Here in the U.S., it seems we all want to optimize our health, and weight is a huge part of that. We want to have a positive ratio of lean muscle mass to fat, so a reliable way to determine that ratio would be very helpful as we set our health and exercise goals.
But do we already have such a method? Before we get to that, let’s look at a little history.
People have worried about their weight ever since humans in ancient times moved from a sustenance diet to one that permitted overeating. Hippocrates, the 5th century BCE Greek “Father of Medicine,” was among the first to declare that obesity was not only a disease in itself, but that it could lead to other disorders – and he credited the Egyptians before him for that insight.
But it wasn’t until the mid-19th century that such concerns led a Belgian statistician to ponder how to devise a scale that could measure people’s size and weight compared to others – potentially many others.
Adolphe Quetelet developed a formula for standardizing individual measurements into a simple number. These numbers formed a tool that could be employed by public health officials and others to understand the range of human dietary and health experiences. Many years later, in the 1970s, this tool was codified as the body mass index, and we have been using it unchanged since it was first developed by Quetelet.
RECOMMENDED ARTICLE: What exactly is fat? Find out the difference between what we call "fat", and what your body considers "fat cells" in "The Skinny On Fat Cells: They're Just Another Body Tissue"
The formula for assessing one’s BMI is simple. It’s so uncomplicated, in fact, that you see it used in gyms all around the world to gauge progress in aerobics or body-building. The formula takes your weight and divides it by the square of your height to compute a number, and this number is your BMI. (It’s very straightforward when using kilograms and centimeters. But if you do the calculation using pounds and inches, you need to multiply the results by 703 for the BMI number.)
But why trust your own math? The National Institutes of Health has its own BMI calculator. Just click on this link to get your own number.
This method is all well and good, as far as it goes. However, when you pull it apart, BMI has numerous problems as a predictive or diagnostic tool. Here are seven of them:
Want to know what diseases might be overlooked due to an inaccurate BMI? The list is long, so hold tight: heart disease; high blood pressure; type 2 diabetes; gallstones; breathing problems, including sleep apnea; certain cancers, including endometrial, breast, colon, kidney, gallbladder, and liver; cholesterol and triglyceride levels; stroke; osteoarthritis; and chronic inflammation. Whew! Please see your doctor if you’re concerned about the health risks of being overweight.
Given what we know about the limitations of the body mass index, you might be wondering if there are other tests that are more accurate than BMI for individuals. Indeed, there are numerous methods of testing body composition and body fat that are accurate. These include:
So why aren’t people flocking to these methods? Well, they’re just not that easy to do. For example, information about body measurements is still officially “investigational.” Most of these tests have to be done and interpreted by medical professionals, and they’re expensive and complicated. When it comes to underwater weigh-ins, have you ever seen one? No, neither have I.
After all this, you might think I’m working up to a big conclusion – BMI is tripe! It’s not worth the effort (or the math)! So, you might be surprised when I tell you that, for all its limitations, the lowly BMI has some uses that are still valuable.
For starters, it’s been around for about 150 years, which gives it a rather long head start against the newer arrivals. We (now) know what it doesn’t do – and what it does, which is to give a simple number to assign to our general health. That number can give us a sense of how we’re progressing over time. (But, to be fair, a simpler measurement of our waist circumference can help just as much.)
The CDC recommends BMI as being:
Plus, it’s a simple, quick measurement to take, and the result is a single number that can generally place people at high, medium, or low risk of weight-related medical issues.
We know now that BMI is frequently used and frequently misused. It’s a test that gets more accurate when you view it from farther away; viewed too closely, at the individual level, it can be an invitation to skewed results. But it’s an easier way to get your bearings in the world of health and fitness than, say, just weighing yourself daily.
Based on what we’ve discussed, it is probably better for you to make an appointment with a physician than to accept a personal trainer’s offer to test you for BMI. You’ll get a better, more reliable answer about your health and weight-related risk factors. And you may sleep better too, knowing you have a reliable, comprehensive picture of your health, your weight, and your overall body composition.
Remember, BMI does one thing well: It measures weight-to-height ratio. The rest of what you might want to know (such as a body fat analysis) cannot be revealed by BMI. So jump on your scale as often as you like, but for an accurate assessment of your health and any associated risks, you might be better off keeping tabs on your waist size.
Comfort foods offer many (psychological, if not physical) benefits. The dopamine release made possible by these foods...
Body fat is often scrutinized when evaluating health and diet, but what exactly is it? Fat cells provide nutrients, and...
The human brain is extraordinary, and the skills we...
Black markets have been created across the world for illegal organ transplants. Mostly in severely poor, developing...
Lowering the birth rate may be the “magic bullet” for addressing current and future climate and population...
Is the human population growing? Yes. Will overpopulation eventually threaten our species? Some leading experts say,...